Mustang Sally
5 stars - based on 1 review
263 Higbie Ln West Islip, NY 11795
(631) 661-7286 Categories: Bar Price Range: $$ Takes Reservations: Yes
Perfect For
  • Amazing View (24)
  • Authentic Ethnic Eats (52)
  • Bar Action (134)
  • Bartenders With Skills (55)
  • Beer Gardens (4)
  • Beer on Tap (81)
  • Best Burgers on Long Island (38)
  • Best Hot Dogs on LI (4)
  • Big Groups (123)
  • Birthdays (89)
  • Breakfast: The Best Spots (26)
  • Brunch (110)
  • Buffalo Wing Fix (31)
  • Cheap Eats (13)
  • Classic Establishment (41)
  • Craft Beer (37)
  • Date Night (138)
  • Dinner with the In-Laws (65)
  • Happy Hour (114)
  • Ladies Night Thursdays (26)
  • Live Music on the Weekends (47)
  • Long Island Restaurant Week (1)
  • Long Islands Top Restaurants (140)
  • Lounge (39)
  • Menu Available (223)
  • Monday Night Football (11)
  • Neighborhood Pick (31)
  • Outdoor Dining (58)
  • Outdoor Lounge (34)
  • Pizza Fix (32)
  • Pizza Fix: Top Long Island Pizza Pies (12)
  • Pool Tables (6)
  • Quality Food (57)
  • Sports Action (42)
  • Summer Hangout (12)
  • Sunday Football (32)
  • Sushi Spots (26)
  • T.V Features (5)
  • The Best Seafood On LI (37)
  • Top Nassau County Restaurants (79)
  • Top Suffolk County Restaurants (45)
  • Vegetarians (55)
  • Waterfront View (26)
Neighborhood
  • Albertson (4)
  • Amagansett (7)
  • Amityville (8)
  • Atlantic Beach (2)
  • Babylon (16)
  • Baiting Hollow (1)
  • Bay Shore (16)
  • Bayville (4)
  • Bellmore (7)
  • Bellport (3)
  • Bethpage (7)
  • Blue Point (3)
  • Bohemia (2)
  • Bridgehampton (1)
  • Calverton (2)
  • Carle Place (14)
  • Centereach (1)
  • Centerport (1)
  • Cold Spring Harbor (2)
  • Commack (5)
  • Coral Springs (1)
  • Coram (2)
  • Deer Park (2)
  • Dix Hills (1)
  • East Hampton (23)
  • East Hills (1)
  • East Islip (4)
  • East Meadow (11)
  • East Northport (3)
  • East Norwich (4)
  • East Patchogue (2)
  • East Rockaway (1)
  • East Setauket (2)
  • Farmingdale (14)
  • Fire Island Pines (1)
  • Floral Park (11)
  • Franklin Square (6)
  • Freeport (7)
  • Garden City (27)
  • Garden City Park (6)
  • Glen Cove (7)
  • Glen Head (4)
  • Glen Oaks (1)
  • Great Neck (8)
  • Greenlawn (2)
  • Greenport (5)
  • Greenvale (5)
  • Hampton Bays (7)
  • Hauppauge (6)
  • Hewlett (1)
  • Hicksville (16)
  • Holbrook (1)
  • Huntington (34)
  • Huntington Station (4)
  • Island Park (3)
  • Islip (3)
  • Jamesport (3)
  • Jericho (5)
  • Lake Grove (2)
  • Lawrence (2)
  • Levittown (3)
  • Locust Valley (5)
  • Long Beach (8)
  • Lynbrook (4)
  • Manhasset (6)
  • Massapequa (10)
  • Massapequa Park (2)
  • Mattituck (6)
  • Medford (2)
  • Melville (5)
  • Merrick (13)
  • Miller Place (1)
  • Mineola (26)
  • Montauk (6)
  • Nesconset (2)
  • New Hyde Park (19)
  • Northport (6)
  • Oakdale (1)
  • Oceanside (3)
  • Oyster Bay (3)
  • Patchogue (14)
  • Plainview (5)
  • Port Jefferson (17)
  • Port Washington (5)
  • Quogue (1)
  • Riverhead (2)
  • Rockville Centre (17)
  • Rocky Point (4)
  • Ronkonkoma (1)
  • Roslyn (19)
  • Roslyn Heights (9)
  • Sag Harbor (6)
  • Sayville (8)
  • Sea Cliff (3)
  • Seaford (4)
  • Shelter Island (7)
  • Shelter Island Heights (1)
  • Shirley (6)
  • Smithtown (33)
  • Southampton (5)
  • Southold (12)
  • Stony Brook (5)
  • Syosset (10)
  • Valley Stream (1)
  • Wading River (9)
  • Wainscott (3)
  • Wantagh (10)
  • Water Mill (4)
  • West Islip (9)
  • West Sayville (3)
  • Westbury (19)
  • Westhampton Beach (9)
  • Williston Park (16)
  • Woodbury (13)
Cuisine
  • American (152)
  • American Bistro (9)
  • Asian Fusion (19)
  • Bar & Grill (45)
  • BBQ (6)
  • Breakfast/Lunch/Brunch (7)
  • Burgers (30)
  • Cajun (5)
  • Carribean (1)
  • Chettinadu (1)
  • Chinese (6)
  • Continental (24)
  • Cuban (3)
  • Delicatessen (5)
  • Desserts (6)
  • Diner (7)
  • Eastern European (1)
  • Eclectic (7)
  • Fondue (2)
  • French - Bistro/Brasserie (13)
  • Gastropub (2)
  • German (8)
  • Greek / Mediterranean (24)
  • Hawaiian (1)
  • Indian (14)
  • International (1)
  • Irish Pub & Restaurant (13)
  • Italian (80)
  • Japanese & Hibachi (25)
  • Kosher (5)
  • Latin American (4)
  • Mexican (12)
  • Middle Eastern (9)
  • Persian (5)
  • Peruvian (2)
  • Pizza (58)
  • Portuguese/Rodizio (8)
  • Seafood, Oyster Bar (14)
  • Seasonal New American (1)
  • Southern BBQ (2)
  • Southwestern (2)
  • Spanish (5)
  • Steak House (47)
  • Sushi (11)
  • Tapas (5)
  • Tea Room (2)
  • Tex-Mex (3)
  • Thai (3)
  • Vegetarian (2)
  • Vietnamese (1)
Long Island Blogger
Perfect For
  • Amazing View (24)
  • Authentic Ethnic Eats (52)
  • Bar Action (134)
  • Bartenders With Skills (55)
  • Beer Gardens (4)
  • Beer on Tap (81)
  • Best Burgers on Long Island (38)
  • Best Hot Dogs on LI (4)
  • Big Groups (123)
  • Birthdays (89)
  • Breakfast: The Best Spots (26)
  • Brunch (110)
  • Buffalo Wing Fix (31)
  • Cheap Eats (13)
  • Classic Establishment (41)
  • Craft Beer (37)
  • Date Night (138)
  • Dinner with the In-Laws (65)
  • Happy Hour (114)
  • Ladies Night Thursdays (26)
  • Live Music on the Weekends (47)
  • Long Island Restaurant Week (1)
  • Long Islands Top Restaurants (140)
  • Lounge (39)
  • Menu Available (223)
  • Monday Night Football (11)
  • Neighborhood Pick (31)
  • Outdoor Dining (58)
  • Outdoor Lounge (34)
  • Pizza Fix (32)
  • Pizza Fix: Top Long Island Pizza Pies (12)
  • Pool Tables (6)
  • Quality Food (57)
  • Sports Action (42)
  • Summer Hangout (12)
  • Sunday Football (32)
  • Sushi Spots (26)
  • T.V Features (5)
  • The Best Seafood On LI (37)
  • Top Nassau County Restaurants (79)
  • Top Suffolk County Restaurants (45)
  • Vegetarians (55)
  • Waterfront View (26)
Neighborhood
  • Albertson (4)
  • Amagansett (7)
  • Amityville (8)
  • Atlantic Beach (2)
  • Babylon (16)
  • Baiting Hollow (1)
  • Bay Shore (16)
  • Bayville (4)
  • Bellmore (7)
  • Bellport (3)
  • Bethpage (7)
  • Blue Point (3)
  • Bohemia (2)
  • Bridgehampton (1)
  • Calverton (2)
  • Carle Place (14)
  • Centereach (1)
  • Centerport (1)
  • Cold Spring Harbor (2)
  • Commack (5)
  • Coral Springs (1)
  • Coram (2)
  • Deer Park (2)
  • Dix Hills (1)
  • East Hampton (23)
  • East Hills (1)
  • East Islip (4)
  • East Meadow (11)
  • East Northport (3)
  • East Norwich (4)
  • East Patchogue (2)
  • East Rockaway (1)
  • East Setauket (2)
  • Farmingdale (14)
  • Fire Island Pines (1)
  • Floral Park (11)
  • Franklin Square (6)
  • Freeport (7)
  • Garden City (27)
  • Garden City Park (6)
  • Glen Cove (7)
  • Glen Head (4)
  • Glen Oaks (1)
  • Great Neck (8)
  • Greenlawn (2)
  • Greenport (5)
  • Greenvale (5)
  • Hampton Bays (7)
  • Hauppauge (6)
  • Hewlett (1)
  • Hicksville (16)
  • Holbrook (1)
  • Huntington (34)
  • Huntington Station (4)
  • Island Park (3)
  • Islip (3)
  • Jamesport (3)
  • Jericho (5)
  • Lake Grove (2)
  • Lawrence (2)
  • Levittown (3)
  • Locust Valley (5)
  • Long Beach (8)
  • Lynbrook (4)
  • Manhasset (6)
  • Massapequa (10)
  • Massapequa Park (2)
  • Mattituck (6)
  • Medford (2)
  • Melville (5)
  • Merrick (13)
  • Miller Place (1)
  • Mineola (26)
  • Montauk (6)
  • Nesconset (2)
  • New Hyde Park (19)
  • Northport (6)
  • Oakdale (1)
  • Oceanside (3)
  • Oyster Bay (3)
  • Patchogue (14)
  • Plainview (5)
  • Port Jefferson (17)
  • Port Washington (5)
  • Quogue (1)
  • Riverhead (2)
  • Rockville Centre (17)
  • Rocky Point (4)
  • Ronkonkoma (1)
  • Roslyn (19)
  • Roslyn Heights (9)
  • Sag Harbor (6)
  • Sayville (8)
  • Sea Cliff (3)
  • Seaford (4)
  • Shelter Island (7)
  • Shelter Island Heights (1)
  • Shirley (6)
  • Smithtown (33)
  • Southampton (5)
  • Southold (12)
  • Stony Brook (5)
  • Syosset (10)
  • Valley Stream (1)
  • Wading River (9)
  • Wainscott (3)
  • Wantagh (10)
  • Water Mill (4)
  • West Islip (9)
  • West Sayville (3)
  • Westbury (19)
  • Westhampton Beach (9)
  • Williston Park (16)
  • Woodbury (13)
Cuisine
  • American (152)
  • American Bistro (9)
  • Asian Fusion (19)
  • Bar & Grill (45)
  • BBQ (6)
  • Breakfast/Lunch/Brunch (7)
  • Burgers (30)
  • Cajun (5)
  • Carribean (1)
  • Chettinadu (1)
  • Chinese (6)
  • Continental (24)
  • Cuban (3)
  • Delicatessen (5)
  • Desserts (6)
  • Diner (7)
  • Eastern European (1)
  • Eclectic (7)
  • Fondue (2)
  • French - Bistro/Brasserie (13)
  • Gastropub (2)
  • German (8)
  • Greek / Mediterranean (24)
  • Hawaiian (1)
  • Indian (14)
  • International (1)
  • Irish Pub & Restaurant (13)
  • Italian (80)
  • Japanese & Hibachi (25)
  • Kosher (5)
  • Latin American (4)
  • Mexican (12)
  • Middle Eastern (9)
  • Persian (5)
  • Peruvian (2)
  • Pizza (58)
  • Portuguese/Rodizio (8)
  • Seafood, Oyster Bar (14)
  • Seasonal New American (1)
  • Southern BBQ (2)
  • Southwestern (2)
  • Spanish (5)
  • Steak House (47)
  • Sushi (11)
  • Tapas (5)
  • Tea Room (2)
  • Tex-Mex (3)
  • Thai (3)
  • Vegetarian (2)
  • Vietnamese (1)
Long Island BloggerLong Island BloggerLong Island BloggerLong Island Blogger

Mustang Sally (Bar)

263 Higbie Ln |  West Islip |  NY | 11795 | (631) 661-7286 | Get Direction

Mustang Sally, located at 263 Higbie Ln, has an atmosphere thatas bordering on dive. Donat take a date therea"unless sheas cool as hell and is super low-maintenancea"but itas a good place to chill and unwind. -Review of Mustang Sally


Mustang Sally, located at 263 Higbie Ln, has an atmosphere thatas bordering on dive. Donat take a date therea"unless sheas cool as hell and is super low-maintenancea"but itas a good place to chill and unwind. -Review of Mustang Sally


Other Recomendations

  • Long Island Blogger:

    Trot Inn
    191 Higbie Ln | West Islip | NY | 11795

  • Long Island Blogger:

    Nonnina
    999 Montauk Hwy | West Islip | NY | 11795

  • Long Island Blogger:

    Parkwood Cafe
    399 Montauk Highway | West Islip | NY | 11795

  • Long Island Blogger:

    Villa Monaco
    778 Montauk Highway | West Islip | NY | 11795

  • Long Island Blogger:

    Our Little Italy
    636 Union Boulevard | West Islip | NY | 11795

  • Long Island Blogger:

    Cafe Mojo
    191 Higbie Lane | West Islip | NY | 11795

Links

About LI Blogger

Legal

RP Media Network

©2019 LI Blogger, Inc.