Refined American Dining in Huntington

135 W Gate Dr | Huntington

Upscale Italian Dining with a Cozy Wine Bar Atmosphere in Amityville

184 Broadway | Amityville

A North Fork Italian Classic with Heart and Heritage

28350 Main Road | Cutchogue

Authentic Mediterranean Flavor in a Warm, Welcoming Setting

1060 Route 25A | Mount Sinai

A Warm Neighborhood Italian Spot With Classic Flavors & Family-Friendly Charm

304 Route 25A | Mount Sinai

Fresh American Eats with Cozy Neighborhood Charm in Amityville

393 Bayview Ave | Amityville

Classic Pub Fare with a Coastal Twist

102 Washington Dr | Centerport

Montauk’s Cozy Cafe for Fresh Breakfast and Brunch

47 South Elmwood Avenue | Montauk

A Nostalgic Diner with Timeless Flavor

Main Street | Bridgehampton

Local flavor, friendly faces, and pub classics done right.

200 Orinoco Dr | Brightwaters

Classic Pub Fare with Irish Hospitality

386 Montauk Hwy | Center Moriches

Mineola’s Cozy Hideaway for All-Day Comfort Food

95 Mineola Blvd | Mineola

Rustic charm meets refined comfort food at this North Fork staple, where every bite feels like home.

2218 Sound Avenue | Baiting Hollow

A Cozy Breakfast Gem in Amityville

194A Park Ave. | Amityville

Homestyle Comfort in Every Bite

334 Main Street | Center Moriches

A Timeless North Fork Favorite

27850 Main Rd | Cutchogue

Reviewed by a Long Island Food Explorer who believes every neighborhood deserves a great Italian spot.

1203 Broadway | Hewlett

Elevated Italian Dining in Bridgehampton

2402 Montauk Hwy | Bridgehampton

Reviewed by The Long Island Eats Team – spotlighting authentic flavors and unforgettable dining experiences across Suffolk County.

356 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway | Hauppauge

Upscale Dining with Coastal Elegance in Baiting Hollow

100 Fox Hill Drive | Baiting Hollow

Rustic Mediterranean flavors, generous plates, and serene waterfront dining on Fort Pond.

11 South Emery Street | Montauk

Sweet Treats & Global Eats in the Heart of Bellmore, NY

322 Bedford Avenue | Bellmore

Big steaks, bold flavor, and classic comfort in Calverton.

4362 Middle Country Road (Route 25) | Calverton

Cozy comfort food, friendly Irish charm, and laid-back Montauk hospitality in every bite.

432 West Lake Drive | Montauk

From brick-oven pizza to signature pastas, King Umberto delivers Italian perfection with neighborhood warmth.

1339 Hempstead Turnpike | Elmont

Authentic Italian with Timeless Charm

611 Montauk Highway | Center Moriches

Authentic Turkish & Mediterranean Flavors in Smithtown

341 Terry Rd | Smithtown

Holbrook’s Beloved Italian Restaurant for Classic Dishes, Fine Wine, and Family Dining.

400 Furrows Road | Holbrook

Serving up pizza, pasta, and tradition by the slice.

201 Orinoco Drive | Brightwaters

Classic Italian Dining with a Modern, Family-Style Touch

300 West Jericho Turnpike | Huntington

Classic Pub Fare Meets Neighborhood Charm

371 New York Avenue | Huntington

Where Local Flavor Meets Laid-Back Fun

545 Fulton St | Farmingdale

Elevated American Fare with Coastal Charm in Bayville, NY

275 Bayville Ave. | Bayville

The Mill House Inn in East Hampton pairs cozy charm with gourmet, locally inspired cuisine.

31 North Main Street | East Hampton

A Timeless Jericho Tradition with Classic American Fare

585 North Broadway | Jericho

Classic German-American Fare in a Cozy Bellmore Hideaway

1940 Bellmore Ave | Bellmore