If you're in search of a cozy countryside restaurant on Long Island that delivers both comfort and culinary excellence, Cooperage Inn in Baiting Hollow is a must-visit. This warm, rustic-chic eatery effortlessly blends farm-to-table sensibility with upscale American classics, offering a memorable dining experience year-round.

🍽️ Food & Drink

The menu at Cooperage Inn is hearty, seasonal, and loaded with flavor. Start with the Butternut Squash Bisque or the French Onion Soup, both of which set the tone for a comfort-filled meal. The Crab Cakes are another standout starter—golden, meaty, and perfectly seasoned.

When it comes to entrées, you can’t go wrong with the Braised Short Ribs—fall-off-the-bone tender and served with rich pan jus and mashed potatoes. The Chicken Pot Pie is a local favorite: creamy, flavorful, and wrapped in a perfectly flaky crust. For seafood lovers, the Stuffed Flounder or Grilled Salmon are light, fresh, and satisfying.

Don’t skip dessert—the Peach Crisp and Coconut Layer Cake are house-made and worth every bite. Pair your meal with a glass from their curated Long Island wine list or try one of their seasonal cocktails.

🌿 Ambiance

Set against the picturesque North Fork landscape, Cooperage Inn offers a farmhouse vibe with plenty of charm. Exposed wooden beams, soft lighting, and a welcoming fireplace make it ideal for a cozy dinner, romantic date night, or celebratory brunch. The outdoor patio is particularly popular in warmer months, offering garden views and live music on select evenings.

📝 Final Thoughts

Whether you're a local or just visiting the wine country of Long Island, Cooperage Inn is a go-to for comforting American fare with a gourmet twist. From its inviting ambiance to its consistently well-executed dishes, it’s a place that feels like home—but tastes like something truly special.