A North Fork Italian Classic with Heart and Heritage

28350 Main Road | Cutchogue

Authentic Mediterranean Flavor in a Warm, Welcoming Setting

1060 Route 25A | Mount Sinai

Fresh American Eats with Cozy Neighborhood Charm in Amityville

393 Bayview Ave | Amityville

Classic Comfort Food With Laid-Back Coastal Energy

222 West Park Avenue | Long Beach

Classic Long Island diner serving hearty comfort food and homemade desserts in a cozy, family-friendly setting.

145 Montauk Highway | Blue Point

A Nostalgic Diner with Timeless Flavor

Main Street | Bridgehampton

A Cozy Brunch Haven in Amityville, NY

55 Merrick Rd. | Amityville

Classic Pub Fare with Irish Hospitality

386 Montauk Hwy | Center Moriches

Where beachside bites, frozen cocktails, and easygoing waterfront vibes make every visit feel like a mini vacation in Point Lookout.

72 Bayside Drive | Point Lookout

A Flavorful Escape to Latin Comfort in Brentwood, NY

1768 Brentwood Road | Brentwood

Bellmore’s Premier Spot for Portuguese Rodízio

2700 Sunrise Highway | Bellmore

A stylish yet welcoming dining spot where Asian-inspired flavors, sushi, and cocktails come together for a memorable night out.

45 Carmans Road | Massapequa

Where sushi meets pasta and classic comfort gets a modern twist.

14 Broadhollow Rd. | Melville

A Laid-Back Seafood Gem on the Montauk Highway

2025 Montauk Highway | Amagansett

Rustic charm meets refined comfort food at this North Fork staple, where every bite feels like home.

2218 Sound Avenue | Baiting Hollow

Classic Indian Cuisine with Elegant Flair

440 Jericho Turnpike | Jericho

Homestyle Comfort in Every Bite

334 Main Street | Center Moriches

Reviewed by a Long Island Food Explorer who believes every neighborhood deserves a great Italian spot.

1203 Broadway | Hewlett

Homestyle Italian Comfort With a Warm, Welcoming Feel

301 Main Street | Islip

A No-Nonsense Local Hangout With Big Flavor and Classic Montauk Attitude

482 W Lake Dr | Montauk

Classic Bethpage diner for comfort food, big portions & late-night bites.

4280 Hempstead Turnpike | Bethpage

Bayport’s Freshest Catch, Served with No Frills and Big Flavor

836 Montauk Highway | Bayport

A fresh, flavorful staple for gourmet cravings on the go.

115 East Main Street | Babylon

A Cozy Hamptons Café for All-Day Eats

2426 Montauk Highway | Bridgehampton

Elevated coastal dining, refined flavors, and breathtaking oceanfront ambiance at Montauk’s luxury resort.

290 Old Montauk Hwy | Montauk

A South Indian Twist in the Hamptons

Main Street | Amagansett

Rustic Mediterranean flavors, generous plates, and serene waterfront dining on Fort Pond.

11 South Emery Street | Montauk

A Nostalgic Landmark Serving Up Classic Comfort and Sweet Tradition

84 Hillside Avenue | Williston Park

Ultra-fresh seafood, standout sushi, and sweeping harbor views at one of Montauk’s most iconic dining spots.

541 East Lake Drive | Montauk

Sweet Treats & Global Eats in the Heart of Bellmore, NY

322 Bedford Avenue | Bellmore

Classic Cuts, Big Portions & True Long Island Comfort

116 Montauk Highway | Islip

Elevated Comfort Food with a Neighborhood Vibe

6005 Jericho Turnpike (Route 25) | Commack

Bold barbecue, big portions, and true roadhouse comfort.

1810 Merrick Road | Merrick

Classic comfort, all-day breakfast, and true hometown diner vibes.

1535 Montauk Highway | Mastic

Classic burgers, crispy comfort eats, and old-school ice cream charm in the heart of Montauk.

695 Montauk Highway | Montauk

A friendly neighborhood pub serving hearty comfort food, crisp pints, and a welcoming bar atmosphere that feels like home.

131 Front Street | Massapequa Park