Gurney's Inn Resort & Spa
5 stars - based on 1 review
290 Old Montauk Hwy Montauk, NY 11954
(631) 668-2345 Categories: Seafood , New American Price Range: $$ Takes Reservations: Yes
×

Gurney's Inn Resort & Spa Montauk

Elevated coastal dining, refined flavors, and breathtaking oceanfront ambiance at Montauk’s luxury resort.
What Kind Of Food Do They Serve: Seafood, New American
Long Island Blogger
Long Island Blogger

Gurney’s Inn Resort & Spa offers one of Montauk’s most elevated dining experiences, combining oceanfront elegance with fresh coastal cuisine and a refined, relaxed atmosphere. Whether you're visiting for a romantic dinner, a celebratory meal, or simply to enjoy the resort's iconic beachfront setting, Gurney’s delivers a dining experience that feels both luxurious and distinctly Montauk.

Food & What to Order
The menu leans into upscale coastal flavors with an emphasis on fresh seafood, high-quality ingredients, and artfully plated dishes. Start with the Oysters on the Half Shell, a refreshing and briny introduction that pairs perfectly with a crisp white wine. Another standout is the Tuna Tartare, known for its bright flavor, silky texture, and light, citrusy finish.

For entrées, the Pan-Seared Sea Bass is a must-try—delicate, perfectly cooked, and complemented by seasonal vegetables. If you're craving pasta, the Lobster Tagliatelle offers rich, comforting flavors with generous pieces of fresh lobster woven through silky noodles. Guests looking for a non-seafood option will appreciate the Filet Mignon, cooked to perfection and presented with a refined touch.

The dessert menu is equally enticing, with options like Crème Brûlée or a Chocolate Mousse Cake that round out the meal beautifully.

Drinks
Gurney’s beverage program is polished and thoughtfully curated. Expect elegant wines, classic cocktails with a coastal twist, and refreshing spritzes perfect for sipping while you soak in ocean views. Signature drinks often highlight botanicals and seasonal flavors that complement the food.

Ambiance
Gurney’s is all about atmosphere—stunning ocean views, contemporary décor, and a serene beachside setting. The dining spaces feel upscale but approachable, ideal for special occasions, intimate dinners, and celebrations. At sunset, the entire space glows, transforming even a simple meal into a memorable experience.

290 Old Montauk Hwy  |  Montauk  |  NY  | 11954 | (631) 668-2345
Near By
Long Island Blogger:

Montauk’s Cozy Cafe for Fresh Breakfast and Brunch

47 South Elmwood Avenue | Montauk

Long Island Blogger:

Rustic Mediterranean flavors, generous plates, and serene waterfront dining on Fort Pond.

11 South Emery Street | Montauk

Long Island Blogger:

Classic bar bites, cold drafts, and lively Montauk energy served all day and night.

697 Montauk Hwy | Montauk

Long Island Blogger:

A Legendary Local Hangout Serving Classic Seafood & Timeless Montauk Vibes

774 Main Street | Montauk

Long Island Blogger:

A Trendy Waterfront Escape With Fresh Flavors & Unmatched Summer Energy

91 Montauk Highway | Montauk

Long Island Blogger:

Classic Coastal Dining With Charming Oceanfront Energy

685 Old Montauk Hwy | Montauk