Inlet Seafood is one of Montauk’s most iconic waterfront restaurants, celebrated for its incredibly fresh seafood, sushi selections, and sweeping views of the harbor. Owned by local fishermen, this spot delivers some of the freshest catches in Montauk, making it a must-visit for seafood lovers seeking an authentic coastal dining experience.

Food & What to Order
The menu features an impressive mix of classic seafood dishes and high-quality sushi. Start with their famous Tuna Tartare, bright, clean, and layered with flavor. The Fried Calamari is another crowd favorite—crispy, tender, and perfectly seasoned.

For entrées, the Grilled Swordfish stands out for its rich flavor and perfect char. The Lobster Roll is another top pick, served generously with sweet, succulent lobster meat. Sushi fans should not miss the Yellowtail Jalapeño Roll, the Montauk Roll, or the simple yet exceptional Salmon Nigiri, all showcasing the restaurant’s unmatched freshness.

If you’re craving something heartier, the Seafood Pasta offers a comforting mix of clams, shrimp, and fish in a flavorful sauce. Paired with their warm bread and butter, it makes for a satisfying meal with a coastal twist.

Drinks
Inlet Seafood’s drink menu complements its food perfectly, offering crisp white wines, refreshing rosés, local beers, and classic cocktails. A chilled glass of Sauvignon Blanc or an Aperol Spritz pairs beautifully with sushi and raw bar items, while a cold draft beer enhances fried seafood dishes.

Ambiance
Set on a hill overlooking the harbor, Inlet Seafood provides some of the most beautiful views in Montauk—especially at sunset. The atmosphere is laid-back but polished, with large windows framing the water and plenty of natural light. It’s ideal for date nights, group dinners, or simply enjoying a relaxed meal with a spectacular backdrop. Outdoor seating in warmer months adds to the experience, making every visit feel like a mini coastal getaway.