Set just off Main Street in Islip, Bayberry Café brings something fresh and inviting to the local dining scene. It’s the kind of place that catches your eye with its charming storefront, pulls you in with the smell of roasted coffee and baked goods, and keeps you coming back with a menu full of thoughtful, feel-good food.

The space is open and airy, with a clean, modern design softened by natural woods, greenery, and warm lighting. Whether you’re seated near the front windows or at a quiet corner table, the ambiance is welcoming and unhurried — ideal for everything from breakfast with friends to working over lunch, or even winding down in the evening with a glass of wine.

Bayberry Café’s menu is rooted in seasonal, locally inspired fare with an emphasis on quality ingredients and simple preparation done right. Mornings feature flaky croissants, avocado toast with house seasoning, and signature egg sandwiches served on fresh-baked bread. As the day rolls on, the café transitions into crisp salads, flatbreads, pressed sandwiches, and small plates that go perfectly with a craft latte or something from their curated wine list.

The vibe is easygoing and stylish, attracting a mix of locals, remote workers, and weekend brunch-goers. Staff are attentive and upbeat, striking that rare balance of professionalism and approachability. The whole experience feels personal — not just a place to eat, but a place to linger and connect.

Whether you're stopping in for a quick coffee or staying for a long, late lunch, Bayberry Café delivers on charm, consistency, and honest flavor — a true standout on Islip’s growing list of must-visit spots.