For years, Brooklyn Square Pizza in Seaford has been the neighborhood go-to for those craving a true slice of New York flavor. Known for its signature square pies, this family-friendly pizzeria delivers the kind of crispy, cheesy, sauce-layered goodness that keeps both longtime regulars and first-timers coming back for more.

From the outside, it’s humble and unassuming — just how a great pizzeria should be. Inside, the vibe is casual, fast-paced, and always welcoming. It’s the kind of place where you're likely to run into neighbors, swap pizza recommendations at the counter, and feel right at home whether you’re grabbing a slice or feeding a hungry family.

The pizza is where Brooklyn Square shines. Their signature square pie has a golden, crispy bottom, rich tomato sauce layered over the cheese in classic upside-down style, and a crust that hits the perfect balance of crunch and chew. It’s a style that pays tribute to old-school Brooklyn pizzerias — hearty, bold, and no shortcuts. You’ll also find round pies, white pizzas, and a solid selection of specialty combinations that offer something for every taste.

Beyond the pizza, the menu includes garlic knots, baked pastas, salads, and heroes — all prepared with the same attention to quality and tradition. Portions are generous, flavors are bold, and everything is made to satisfy.

The word around town is consistent: locals love the reliability, the flavor, and the authentic taste that reminds many of their favorite city slices. It’s not trying to be trendy — just good, honest pizza done right.

For a slice that delivers on crunch, flavor, and classic New York soul, Brooklyn Square Pizza in Seaford continues to hold its place as a true local favorite.