Fatfish On The Water
5 stars - based on 1 review
28 Cottage Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 666-2899 Categories: Seafood Price Range: $$ Takes Reservations: Yes
×

Fatfish on The Water Bay Shore

Coastal Dining Redefined with Sunset Views and Seafood Worth Savoring
What Kind Of Food Do They Serve: Seafood
Long Island Blogger
Long Island Blogger
Long Island Blogger
Long Island Blogger

Perched along the Great South Bay, this waterside destination delivers a dining experience that’s equal parts vibrant and relaxing. With panoramic views, an upbeat atmosphere, and a menu centered around fresh seafood, it’s the kind of place where every meal feels like a getaway.

The setting is nothing short of stunning—especially at golden hour. Guests can dine indoors or on the spacious outdoor deck, where the breeze off the water and views of passing boats create a perfect backdrop for any occasion. Whether you're arriving by car or pulling up by boat, the laid-back yet polished vibe invites you to linger.

The menu leans heavily into seafood, featuring crowd favorites like grilled octopus, lobster tacos, and branzino served whole. Sushi lovers will find fresh, creative rolls, while land-based options like filet mignon and chicken milanese round out the offerings. Everything is presented with flair, with bold flavors and seasonal ingredients taking the spotlight.

Cocktails are a highlight—refreshing, well-crafted, and ideal for sipping by the bay. The lively bar scene blends well with the serene water views, making this a perfect spot for both romantic evenings and group gatherings.

The best time to visit is just before sunset, when the light reflects off the water and the energy of the space hits its peak. For those seeking an elevated coastal dining experience, this bayside gem delivers on every front—from food and drinks to ambiance and unforgettable views.

 

28 Cottage Ave  |  Bay Shore  |  NY  | 11706 | (631) 666-2899
Upcoming Nearby Events

Sat, Sep 13 at 7:00 PM

615 E. Main St | Bay Shore | 11706

Sat, Sep 13 at 8:00 PM

37 W Main St | Bay Shore | 11706

Sat, Oct 4 at 4:30 PM

25 Drexel Dr | Bay Shore | 11706

Sat, Nov 15 at 8:00 PM

37 W Main St | Bay Shore | 11706

Sat, Dec 6 at 5:30 PM

25 Drexel Dr | Bay Shore | 11706

Sat, Dec 6 at 7:00 PM

25 Drexel Dr | Bay Shore | 11706

Near By
Long Island Blogger:

Coastal Kitchen and Daiquiri Bar

12 E Main St | Bay Shore

Long Island Blogger:

Bay Shore's All-American Comfort Food Stop

3 East Main St | Bay Shore

Long Island Blogger:

Lush Mexican Flavors

70 E Main St | Bay Shore

Long Island Blogger:

Surf vibes, bold bites, and breezy sips - Dive brings the beach to Bay Shore.

1 Bay Walk | Bay Shore

Long Island Blogger:

Cuisine: Seafood, American

123 Maple Avenue | Bay Shore

Long Island Blogger:

Bay Shore’s Go-To Surf & Turf Haven

61 West Main St. | Bay Shore