Fatty McGee’s in East Islip is a beloved neighborhood pub where hearty bar food, cold drinks, and a lively atmosphere keep locals coming back. Known for its welcoming vibe and consistent menu, this Irish-inspired bar and grill is the perfect place to grab a pint, catch a game, or enjoy a casual meal with friends.

Food & Drinks
The menu covers all the pub classics, with standout burgers, sandwiches, and wings leading the way. The McGee Burger—juicy, grilled to perfection, and loaded with toppings—is a must-try, while the wings, offered in a variety of sauces, are always a crowd favorite. For comfort food cravings, you can’t go wrong with the shepherd’s pie or the hearty corned beef and cabbage, both nods to the restaurant’s Irish roots.

Seafood lovers will appreciate fried clam strips or a crispy fish sandwich, while lighter options like wraps, salads, and grilled chicken make it easy for everyone to find a favorite. Behind the bar, you’ll find cold beer on tap, classic cocktails, and plenty of drink specials that keep the place buzzing.

Ambiance
Fatty McGee’s is the definition of a neighborhood pub—warm, casual, and unpretentious. The walls are adorned with sports memorabilia and Irish touches, and TVs are always tuned to the latest game. It’s a popular spot for happy hour, late-night bites, and weekend gatherings, making it a reliable choice whether you’re flying solo or meeting a group. In the warmer months, the outdoor patio offers a relaxed space to enjoy a drink under the sun.

What to Order
Start with a basket of wings or mozzarella sticks before digging into the McGee Burger or a plate of shepherd’s pie. Pair your meal with a pint of Guinness or a local craft beer for the full experience.