Jimmy Hays Steakhouse
5 stars - based on 1 review
4310 Austin Boulevard Island Park, NY 11558
(516) 432-5155 Categories: Steak House Price Range: $$ Takes Reservations: Yes
Long Island Blogger
Perfect For
  • Amazing View (22)
  • Authentic Ethnic Eats (48)
  • Bar Action (130)
  • Bartenders With Skills (52)
  • Beer Gardens (3)
  • Beer on Tap (80)
  • Best Burgers on Long Island (37)
  • Best Hot Dogs on LI (4)
  • Big Groups (115)
  • Birthdays (84)
  • Breakfast: The Best Spots (26)
  • Brunch (110)
  • Buffalo Wing Fix (31)
  • Cheap Eats (13)
  • Classic Establishment (39)
  • Craft Beer (36)
  • Date Night (134)
  • Dinner with the In-Laws (59)
  • Happy Hour (111)
  • Ladies Night Thursdays (25)
  • Live Music on the Weekends (46)
  • Long Island Restaurant Week (1)
  • Long Islands Top Restaurants (136)
  • Lounge (36)
  • Menu Available (212)
  • Monday Night Football (10)
  • Neighborhood Pick (31)
  • Outdoor Dining (57)
  • Outdoor Lounge (29)
  • Pizza Fix (30)
  • Pizza Fix: Top Long Island Pizza Pies (14)
  • Pool Tables (6)
  • Quality Food (56)
  • Sports Action (42)
  • Summer Hangout (13)
  • Sunday Football (32)
  • Sushi Spots (25)
  • T.V Features (5)
  • The Best Seafood On LI (37)
  • Top Nassau County Restaurants (78)
  • Top Suffolk County Restaurants (45)
  • Vegetarians (50)
  • Waterfront View (25)
Neighborhood
  • Albertson (4)
  • Amagansett (5)
  • Amityville (8)
  • Atlantic Beach (2)
  • Babylon (16)
  • Baiting Hollow (1)
  • Bay Shore (16)
  • Bayville (4)
  • Bellmore (7)
  • Bellport (3)
  • Bethpage (7)
  • Blue Point (2)
  • Bohemia (2)
  • Bridgehampton (1)
  • Calverton (2)
  • Carle Place (13)
  • Centereach (1)
  • Centerport (1)
  • Cold Spring Harbor (2)
  • Commack (5)
  • Coral Springs (1)
  • Coram (2)
  • Deer Park (2)
  • Dix Hills (1)
  • East Hampton (23)
  • East Hills (1)
  • East Islip (4)
  • East Meadow (11)
  • East Northport (3)
  • East Norwich (4)
  • East Patchogue (2)
  • East Rockaway (1)
  • East Setauket (2)
  • Farmingdale (14)
  • Fire Island Pines (1)
  • Floral Park (11)
  • Franklin Square (6)
  • Freeport (7)
  • Garden City (27)
  • Garden City Park (6)
  • Glen Cove (7)
  • Glen Head (4)
  • Glen Oaks (1)
  • Great Neck (8)
  • Greenlawn (2)
  • Greenport (5)
  • Greenvale (5)
  • Hampton Bays (6)
  • Hauppauge (6)
  • Hewlett (1)
  • Hicksville (15)
  • Holbrook (1)
  • Huntington (34)
  • Huntington Station (3)
  • Island Park (3)
  • Islip (3)
  • Jamesport (3)
  • Jericho (5)
  • Lake Grove (1)
  • Lawrence (2)
  • Levittown (3)
  • Locust Valley (5)
  • Long Beach (8)
  • Lynbrook (4)
  • Manhasset (5)
  • Massapequa (10)
  • Massapequa Park (1)
  • Mattituck (6)
  • Medford (1)
  • Melville (5)
  • Merrick (13)
  • Miller Place (1)
  • Mineola (24)
  • Montauk (6)
  • Nesconset (2)
  • New Hyde Park (13)
  • Northport (5)
  • Oakdale (1)
  • Oceanside (3)
  • Oyster Bay (3)
  • Patchogue (14)
  • Plainview (5)
  • Port Jefferson (17)
  • Port Washington (4)
  • Quogue (1)
  • Riverhead (2)
  • Rockville Centre (17)
  • Rocky Point (4)
  • Ronkonkoma (1)
  • Roslyn (12)
  • Roslyn Heights (6)
  • Sag Harbor (6)
  • Sayville (8)
  • Sea Cliff (3)
  • Seaford (4)
  • Shelter Island (7)
  • Shelter Island Heights (1)
  • Shirley (6)
  • Smithtown (32)
  • Southampton (5)
  • Southold (12)
  • Stony Brook (5)
  • Syosset (10)
  • Valley Stream (1)
  • Wading River (7)
  • Wainscott (3)
  • Wantagh (10)
  • Water Mill (4)
  • West Islip (9)
  • West Sayville (3)
  • Westbury (19)
  • Westhampton Beach (8)
  • Williston Park (15)
  • Woodbury (13)
Cuisine
  • American (145)
  • American Bistro (8)
  • Asian Fusion (18)
  • Bar & Grill (45)
  • BBQ (5)
  • Breakfast/Lunch/Brunch (7)
  • Burgers (28)
  • Cajun (5)
  • Cajun/Creole (1)
  • Caribbean (1)
  • Chettinadu (1)
  • Chinese (6)
  • Continental (24)
  • Cuban (3)
  • Delicatessen (4)
  • Desserts (6)
  • Diner (5)
  • Eclectic (7)
  • Fondue (2)
  • French - Bistro/Brasserie (13)
  • Gastropub (2)
  • German (8)
  • Hawaiian (1)
  • Indian (13)
  • International (1)
  • Irish Pub (3)
  • Italian (78)
  • Japanese & Hibachi (23)
  • Kosher (5)
  • Latin American (4)
  • Locally Sourced (1)
  • Mediterranean (24)
  • Mexican (12)
  • Middle Eastern (9)
  • Persian (5)
  • Peruvian (2)
  • Pizza (47)
  • Portuguese (37)
  • Rodizio (5)
  • Seafood (26)
  • Southern BBQ (2)
  • Southwestern (2)
  • Spanish (5)
  • Steak House (47)
  • Sushi (11)
  • Tapas (5)
  • Tavern (1)
  • Tea Room (2)
  • Tex-Mex (3)
  • Thai (3)
  • Vegetarian (2)
  • Vietnamese (1)
Long Island BloggerLong Island BloggerLong Island BloggerLong Island Blogger

Jimmy Hays Steakhouse In Island Park

What Kind Of Food Do They Serve: Steak House

From the New York of Al Smith, Jimmy Walker, Jack Dempsey and “Abie’s Irish Rose” came the colorful Jimmy McCluskey, founder of the first McCluskey’s more than three quarters of century ago. A remarkable man – filled with a zest for living, hard work, fun and the finest of food and service – became a legend in his time. A multitude of ardent admirers flocked to McCluskey’s to see and talk with Jimmy (who always had a sparkling and witty comment on the passing scene), and to enjoy the steaks, chops and lobsters that he prepared. After more than ninety years of living, Jimmy left us for a kinder, nicer and more gentle world. Today, Jimmy’s grandson, Jimmy Hays carries on the splendid McCluskey Tradition (you will see him in the restaurant dressed as his grandfather was more than fifty years ago – white apron and white trousers) greeting in a most affable way the children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren of those who knew and loved Jimmy McCluskey so long ago.

Venue Attributes

From the New York of Al Smith, Jimmy Walker, Jack Dempsey and “Abie’s Irish Rose” came the colorful Jimmy McCluskey, founder of the first McCluskey’s more than three quarters of century ago. A remarkable man – filled with a zest for living, hard work, fun and the finest of food and service – became a legend in his time. A multitude of ardent admirers flocked to McCluskey’s to see and talk with Jimmy (who always had a sparkling and witty comment on the passing scene), and to enjoy the steaks, chops and lobsters that he prepared. After more than ninety years of living, Jimmy left us for a kinder, nicer and more gentle world. Today, Jimmy’s grandson, Jimmy Hays carries on the splendid McCluskey Tradition (you will see him in the restaurant dressed as his grandfather was more than fifty years ago – white apron and white trousers) greeting in a most affable way the children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren of those who knew and loved Jimmy McCluskey so long ago.

4310 Austin Boulevard |  Island Park |  NY | 11558 | (516) 432-5155
Get Direction

 

Other Recommendations

©2021 LI Blogger, Inc.