If you’re craving old-school, no-frills New York-style pizza in Huntington, Little Vincent’s is a local institution that lives up to its reputation. Known for its casual charm and legendary “cold cheese slice,” this neighborhood favorite has been serving up crave-worthy pies for decades.

What to Order

Start with the classic cheese slice—thin, crisp on the bottom, and just the right balance of sauce and gooey mozzarella. But the real must-try is the Cold Cheese Slice: a hot slice topped with a mound of cold, shredded mozzarella. It might sound strange at first, but it’s a genius move—especially for late-night bites when the extra cheese hits perfectly.

Looking for more variety? Their pepperoni slice is bold and greasy in the best way, while the white slice (ricotta, garlic, and mozzarella) offers a rich, creamy contrast. Whole pies are generously sized and ideal for sharing, and the garlic knots are worth adding on—soft, buttery, and just garlicky enough.

Though it’s a pizza-first kind of spot, they also serve subs, calzones, and baked ziti for those looking to change things up. Portions are generous, and the prices are still surprisingly reasonable for a prime Huntington Village location.

Drinks

Little Vincent’s keeps it simple. You’ll find the usual selection of fountain sodas and bottled beverages, perfect for washing down a cheesy slice. While there’s no alcohol served, it’s the kind of place you drop into before or after a night out on the town.

Ambiance

Expect a no-frills, late-night pizzeria feel. There’s nothing fancy here—just tiled floors, bright lighting, and a few tables along the wall. But that’s part of the charm. It’s fast, friendly, and always buzzing, especially after hours when the bar crowds pour in. There’s a constant flow of pizza lovers—from locals to out-of-towners—grabbing a slice and soaking in the nostalgic atmosphere.

Final Bite

Little Vincent’s Pizza is a slice of Huntington tradition. It’s not trying to reinvent the wheel—it’s serving it hot, fast, and with a New York attitude. Whether you’re a first-timer or a regular, this is the spot for a satisfying, cheesy fix that hits the mark every time. Don’t leave without trying the cold cheese slice—it’s a cult classic for a reason.