If you're searching for a vibrant, no-frills bar experience with classic comfort food, cold drinks, and great company, Mary Carroll’s in Babylon, NY, delivers all that and more. This local favorite blends the laid-back charm of an Irish pub with a lively nightlife vibe that keeps guests coming back for round after round.

Food & Drinks

The menu at Mary Carroll’s leans into crave-worthy pub staples. Their juicy burgers, perfectly crisp wings, and loaded nachos are bar food at its best—perfect for soaking up a pint or two. The buffalo wings strike the right balance of heat and flavor, and the mozzarella sticks are always a crowd-pleaser. While the menu isn’t sprawling, what they do, they do well—and it's consistently satisfying.

Drinks are a huge part of the draw here. Whether you’re in the mood for a freshly poured Guinness, a chilled craft beer on tap, or a signature cocktail, the bar is always stocked and the bartenders know how to keep things moving. Happy hour deals make it even easier to stay for “just one more.”

Ambiance

The atmosphere at Mary Carroll’s is energetic, cozy, and unapologetically fun. Expect dim lighting, exposed brick, and a classic bar setup with TVs tuned to sports, especially on game nights. The music is loud enough to keep the energy high, but you can still have a conversation without shouting. On weekends, the crowd picks up with younger locals and longtime regulars blending seamlessly.

The Verdict

Mary Carroll’s is not your upscale date-night spot—it’s your go-to for casual meetups, pregame drinks, or letting loose with friends. It’s a neighborhood bar with personality, affordable bites, and a solid drink lineup. If you're in Babylon and craving a cold beer and some bar food with a buzz in the air, Mary Carroll’s checks every box.