Tucked away in East Patchogue, Pine Grove Inn is a charming, history-rich restaurant that’s been serving up hearty American and German cuisine for generations. Housed in a building that dates back to the 1800s, the restaurant blends vintage ambiance with a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere that makes it a favorite for locals and visitors alike.

Inside, you’ll find wood-beamed ceilings, warm lighting, and a rustic, lodge-style interior that feels timeless. In the warmer months, the large outdoor beer garden and patio seating area offer a relaxed, scenic setting for al fresco dining and drinks under the trees.

The menu is a celebration of classic comfort food with strong German influences. Standouts include the Wiener Schnitzel, Sauerbraten, and Jäger Schnitzel—all served with traditional sides like red cabbage, spaetzle, and warm potato salad. The Prime Rib and Grilled Pork Chops are excellent options for meat lovers, while lighter dishes like Grilled Salmon or Chicken Francaise offer something for everyone.

Seasonal specials and rotating soups add variety, and portions are generous across the board. Don’t skip the Potato Pancakes or the house-made Apple Strudel for dessert—they’re Pine Grove staples.

The full-service bar offers German and domestic beers on tap, classic cocktails, and wine, making it a great spot for happy hour or a casual drink before dinner. Live music on weekends and themed holiday dinners (especially around Oktoberfest) keep the vibe festive year-round.

With its unique blend of historic charm, authentic flavors, and welcoming service, Pine Grove Inn is more than just a restaurant—it’s a local tradition that delivers consistency, quality, and a comforting, old-world dining experience.