Located in charming East Norwich, Rothmann’s Steakhouse delivers a refined yet inviting steakhouse experience, combining top-quality cuts with classic ambiance and polished service. It’s the kind of place perfect for special nights—think celebrations, date nights, or those evenings when only a perfectly grilled ribeye will do.

The dining room exudes heritage and elegance: rich wood paneling, leather-upholstered seating, crisp white linens, and flattering lighting set a warm and upscale tone without feeling overly formal. Whether seated at a cozy table or near the vibrant bar, the setting strikes the ideal balance between old-world charm and modern comfort.

The menu is centered on premium steaks—select the Prime Ribeye, Filet Mignon, or Bone-In Sirloin, each dry-aged in-house for depth of flavor and expertly grilled to your preference. Steaks have classic sides like Twice-Baked Potato, Creamed Spinach, and Truffle Mac & Cheese. Seafood and surf & turf options—such as Lobster Tail, Jumbo Shrimp Scampi, and Seared Chilean Sea Bass—provide flavorful alternatives and elevate the experience.

Start strong with shareable appetizers, from Beef Carpaccio to Shrimp Cocktail and the indulgent Crab and Spinach Dip. Classic Caesar and wedge salads are crisp and well-executed. Don’t skip dessert—options like New York Cheesecake, Chocolate Lava Cake, and a decadent Bread Pudding deliver a satisfying sweet finish.

The bar menu is equally impressive, with curated wines featuring bold California cabernets, elegant European selections, and classic cocktails like Old Fashioned and Manhattan made with care. The service is polished, attentive, and non-intrusive, and the knowledgeable staff ensures everything from plating to wine pairing enhances the meal.

With its elevated menu, refined ambiance, and focus on service, Rothmann’s Steakhouse stands out as a premier destination for refined steak lovers on Long Island. Whether planning a memorable evening or treating yourself to a classic steakhouse feast, Rothmann’s delivers on every level.