If you’re craving bold flavors and a taste of tradition, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Carle Place, NY is the perfect stop. Known for its signature coal-fired oven and commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients, this restaurant delivers unforgettable pizza, wings, and Italian-American classics in a lively, casual setting.

Food & What to Order

The star of the menu is the coal-fired pizza—thin, crisp, and loaded with flavor. Popular picks include the classic Margherita with fresh mozzarella and basil, or the Meatball & Ricotta pizza, which balances savory richness with creamy texture. Beyond pizza, Anthony’s wings are legendary: baked in the coal oven, they’re crispy on the outside, tender inside, and best enjoyed with caramelized onions and fresh bread. Other must-try items include the Eggplant Marino, Italian-style sandwiches, and a variety of hearty salads that complement the heavier entrées. Portions are generous, making it easy to share family-style.

Drinks & Pairings

Anthony’s offers a well-rounded drink menu featuring craft beers, Italian wines, and refreshing cocktails. A cold pint pairs perfectly with wings, while a glass of red wine elevates the pizza and pasta experience. Happy hour specials and seasonal drinks make it a great spot for both casual evenings and small celebrations.

Ambiance & Vibe

The atmosphere at Anthony’s is upbeat yet comfortable, with an open kitchen that showcases the coal-fired oven at work. Rustic décor and warm lighting set the tone for family dinners, date nights, or casual gatherings with friends. TVs around the bar area make it a go-to for sports fans, while the spacious dining room ensures groups of all sizes feel welcome.