Tucked along a quiet street in the heart of Roslyn, Diane’s Bakery Café has been serving up small-town charm with big flavor for over 40 years. Known for its artisan pies, made-from-scratch cookies, and cozy café eats, it remains one of the most beloved bakeries on Long Island—a local treasure for generations.

A Quaint, Timeless Setting

The venue feels like something out of a storybook. Step inside and you’re greeted by rustic display cases packed with golden pastries and delicate tarts, all lovingly arranged. The space is warm and inviting, with charming café seating tucked just behind the bakery—a perfect spot to sip coffee, share a slice of pie, or enjoy a fresh panini in peace.

Soft lighting, thoughtful décor, and the gentle hum of conversation give it a cozy energy that’s both nostalgic and refreshing.

The Legacy of Diane

Founded by Diane Margaritis, the bakery has stayed true to its roots—focusing on quality ingredients, consistent recipes, and treating every guest like family. Diane’s commitment to craft and community is evident in every detail, from the handwritten labels to the flawless flakiness of her crusts.

What to Order

Signature Pies & Tarts: The Triple Berry Pie is a must-try—sweet, tangy, and perfectly baked. Other favorites include the Banana Cream Pie, Apple Crumb Tart, and Plum Almond Tart.

Savory Favorites: For a quick meal, the Chicken Pot Pie and Spinach & Mushroom Quiche are standouts. The Turkey Chili is hearty and well-seasoned—ideal on a cool day.

Café Specials: The Chicken Panini with tomato and Asiago cheese is a lunch favorite, while the Sweet Potato Biscuit Breakfast Sandwich brings regulars in every weekend.

Don’t skip dessert: The Raspberry Cheese Squares, Rugalach, and Lemon Bars are customer favorites, especially around the holidays when everything is baked in small batches with care.

The Experience

Expect friendly service and a steady stream of locals, many of whom have been visiting for decades. The vibe is unpretentious and genuine—this isn’t a trendy café with flashy plates. It’s the kind of place where you’ll be greeted with a smile and your coffee just the way you like it.

Final Verdict:
Diane’s Bakery Café is a rare gem—one that blends culinary tradition, personal warmth, and timeless recipes in every bite. Whether you're grabbing a treat to-go or settling in for brunch, it’s the kind of place that reminds you why small, local businesses matter.