The Old Mill Inn in Mattituck is a North Fork treasure that blends coastal charm with relaxed, elevated dining. Housed in a historic waterfront setting, this restaurant delivers scenic views, fresh seafood, and a laid-back atmosphere perfect for date night, weekend outings, or a lingering afternoon meal. The décor is classic coastal — think reclaimed wood, nautical touches, and picture-worthy views of the water.

Start with the local oysters or clam chowder, both showcasing the rich seafood culture of the North Fork. The crab cakes are another favorite, lightly seared with plenty of crab and very little filler. Seafood is the star here, and dishes like the seared scallops, grilled salmon, or lobster roll highlight fresh, balanced flavors and quality ingredients.

If you’re in the mood for something hearty, try the steak frites or braised short ribs, both popular menu choices that pair well with a glass of wine. Speaking of wine, The Old Mill Inn shines with a thoughtful selection of local Long Island pours, craft cocktails, and classic favorites that complement the menu perfectly.

The ambiance is calm and inviting, with attentive service and a pace that encourages you to slow down and enjoy the surroundings. Outdoor seating is a highlight during warm weather, offering breezes off the water and a scenic backdrop that elevates any meal.

Whether you’re a local or just passing through Mattituck, the Old Mill Inn is a memorable stop for coastal dining, fresh seafood, and a warm North Fork vibe. It’s a restaurant that captures the charm of Long Island’s East End in every bite.