Eddie's Pizza
5 stars - based on 1 review
2048 Hillside Avenue New Hyde Park, NY 11040
(516) 354-9780 Categories: Pizza , Italian Price Range: $$ Takes Reservations: Yes
×

Eddie's Pizza New Hyde Park

Eddie’s Pizza New Hyde Park: Home of the Iconic Bar Pie and Timeless Flavor
What Kind Of Food Do They Serve: Pizza, Italian
Long Island Blogger
Long Island Blogger
Long Island Blogger

Eddie’s Pizza in New Hyde Park is more than a pizzeria—it's a Long Island classic. With its rustic, old-school charm, tin ceilings, and cozy booth seating, stepping inside feels like a warm return to simpler times. The inviting atmosphere and nostalgic decor make it a favorite for locals and newcomers alike.

Famous as the birthplace of the legendary “bar pie,” Eddie’s perfected the art of thin-crust pizza. These 10-inch pies are crisp, light, and bursting with flavor. The thin, crunchy crust is layered with a zesty tomato sauce and a generous yet balanced portion of melted cheese—making each bite satisfyingly addictive. It’s the kind of pizza that pairs perfectly with a cold drink and good conversation.

Beyond their signature pies, Eddie’s offers a full-service bar, classic Italian comfort dishes, and a family-friendly environment that welcomes everyone. The restaurant is ideal for casual dinners, quick lunches, or gatherings with friends. Its consistent quality, quick service, and retro vibe keep customers coming back for generations.

For anyone craving a slice of New York pizza history and a truly classic dining experience, Eddie’s Pizza in New Hyde Park delivers every time.

 

2048 Hillside Avenue  |  New Hyde Park  |  NY  | 11040 | (516) 354-9780
Long Island Blogger:

Elegant Indian Dining with Rich Flavors and Warm Hospitality

27111 Union Tpke | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Galo Tavern 18 – Charming, Cozy Pub & Grill in New Hyde Park

265-11 Union Tpke | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Lively Japanese Dining with Fresh Sushi & Interactive Hibachi

2311 Jericho Tpke | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Authentic Chettinadu & South Indian Cuisine in New Hyde Park

1635 Hillside Ave | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Elevated American Dining in the Heart of Floral Park

1218 Jericho Turnpike | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

New Hyde Park’s Laid-Back Spot for Elevated Pub Fare

377 Denton Avenue (Located in the Spring Rock Golf Center) | New Hyde Park