Tucked into the heart of Greenport, First and South is a cozy, no-frills gem that packs serious flavor and warm hospitality into every visit. This spot effortlessly balances rustic charm with a neighborhood hangout vibe—think picnic tables, friendly staff, and the casual buzz of locals and weekenders mingling over craft drinks and hearty bites.

The menu celebrates seasonal and locally sourced ingredients, offering elevated comfort food that’s as approachable as it is satisfying. Start with the buttermilk-fried chicken wings tossed in house hot sauce—crispy, juicy, and addictive. Then go for their signature South Burger, topped with caramelized onions, pickled jalapeños, and creamy chipotle aioli. It’s a messy, mouthwatering masterpiece that pairs perfectly with their local beer selection.

Seafood lovers won’t want to miss the pan-seared fish tacos or the rotating fresh catch entrée—prepared simply to let the flavors shine. And vegetarians aren’t left out; the grain bowl with seasonal vegetables and lemon tahini dressing is bright, wholesome, and surprisingly filling.

On the drink side, First and South serves up a curated list of North Fork wines and local brews, plus some standout cocktails. The cucumber gin fizz is especially refreshing on a summer afternoon out on their welcoming patio.

Ambiance here is casual and charming. Whether you're dining under string lights in the outdoor garden or cozying up indoors on a chilly evening, the setting feels intimate without being stuffy. There’s even occasional live music that adds a touch of small-town magic to the experience.

Perfect for brunch, laid-back dinners, or drinks with friends, First and South nails that elusive blend of quality, comfort, and character. It’s the kind of place where you can walk in once and feel like a regular by dessert.

Pro tip: Come hungry—and don’t skip the warm house-made donuts if they’re on the menu.