Jonathan’s in Garden City Park is one of those rare restaurants that balances old-world charm with contemporary polish. With a menu rooted in Italian-American tradition and an atmosphere that feels both refined and welcoming, it’s the kind of place that works equally well for date night, family dinners, or business lunches.

The ambiance is warm and polished — crisp linens, soft lighting, and a dining room that hums with quiet energy. It’s upscale without being over-the-top, with service that’s professional yet personable, making guests feel genuinely taken care of from the moment they arrive.

The menu offers a wide variety of Italian favorites, all thoughtfully prepared and generously portioned. Start with the baked clams or the eggplant rollatini — both are crowd favorites that showcase traditional flavor done right. The fried calamari is crisp, tender, and a great shareable option.

For mains, the chicken scarpariello is a standout — savory, slightly tangy, and loaded with sausage, peppers, and potatoes. The veal chop parmigiana is a house specialty, served bone-in and smothered in sauce and melted cheese. If you're craving pasta, the lobster ravioli or rigatoni Bolognese are always solid picks, and the portions leave nothing to chance.

Seafood options like the broiled Chilean sea bass or shrimp oreganata bring freshness and depth to the menu, while the steaks and chops round it out with hearty, satisfying options.

Behind the bar, there’s a full selection of classic cocktails, a well-curated wine list, and attentive bartenders who know their craft. A glass of Chianti or a dirty martini makes for the perfect pairing with your meal, and dessert wines are available to cap things off with style.

Dinner service is especially popular on weekends, with a mix of regulars and newcomers filling the dining room. Weeknights are a bit quieter, perfect for those looking to enjoy the same quality in a more intimate setting.

Jonathan’s remains a trusted name for a reason — consistently great food, polished service, and a welcoming space that makes every meal feel just a little bit special.