Mama Theresa’s has been a neighborhood favorite in Garden City Park since 1984, and for good reason. For over 40 years, this family-run pizzeria has built a loyal following by sticking to what it does best—serving consistently delicious, classic New York-style pizza.

The pizza here hits all the right notes. The crust is thin and crisp with just the right chew, topped with a flavorful tomato sauce and gooey, golden mozzarella. Whether you go for a fresh slice at the counter or a full pie for the table, you’ll get that same great taste every time. The Sicilian slice is a standout—thick, airy, and packed with rich tomato flavor and plenty of cheese. It’s the kind of comfort food that brings people back week after week.

Mama Theresa’s doesn’t try to be trendy. The setting is simple and welcoming, with a focus on fast service, hot pizza, and that familiar, nostalgic pizzeria feel. It’s a place where families gather, friends catch up, and locals make it part of their weekly routine.

Decades of quality, consistency, and community ties have made Mama Theresa’s more than just a pizza place—it’s a part of Garden City Park history. When you want a slice of classic Long Island flavor, this is where you go.