Located steps from the marina, Kismet Inn in Kismet, NY is a true Fire Island staple, offering casual seafood-focused fare with unbeatable waterfront views. This laid-back spot feels like an old friend – rustic, beachy, and always buzzing with locals and visitors grabbing a cold beer after a day in the sun.

The menu highlights fresh seafood and comforting classics. Start with their New England Clam Chowder, creamy and loaded with tender clams and potatoes – perfect for a breezy day. Their Fried Calamari is golden, crispy, and served with a tangy marinara sauce, ideal for sharing with friends over drinks.

For mains, the Kismet Lobster Roll is a must-order. Served either warm with butter or chilled with light mayo, it’s piled high with sweet lobster meat in a toasted bun and comes with crisp fries on the side. Another popular pick is their Blackened Mahi Mahi Sandwich, featuring perfectly seasoned fish, lettuce, tomato, and zesty remoulade on a soft bun.

Pair your meal with one of their ice-cold draft beers or go for a classic Fire Island cocktail like their Dark & Stormy, made strong and refreshing with ginger beer and dark rum. Their drink menu keeps it simple, with local favorites and summer staples to keep you refreshed as you soak in the marina views.

The ambiance here is casual and lively, with nautical decor, a wraparound deck, and picnic tables that fill up fast on sunny weekends. It’s the type of place where sandy feet are welcome, families gather after a beach day, and boaters dock for lunch and sunset dinners.

For those visiting Fire Island, Kismet Inn remains an essential stop for unfussy seafood, classic American eats, and that quintessential salty-air dining experience right by the water.