Located in the heart of Smithtown, Old Street Pub is a beloved neighborhood spot that blends casual charm with hearty, satisfying food and a welcoming, come-as-you-are atmosphere. With its brick-lined walls, vintage décor, and cozy booths, the space feels like a true Long Island institution—familiar, unpretentious, and always lively.

The menu leans heavily into classic American pub fare with a few unexpected twists. The Prime Rib is a house favorite—tender, juicy, and served with all the fixings. Fans of comfort food won’t want to miss the Shepherd’s Pie or the Chicken Pot Pie, both rich, filling, and packed with flavor. The Pub Burger, stacked with bacon and cheddar on a brioche bun, is a crowd-pleaser, especially when paired with their crispy seasoned fries.

Seafood options like the Baked Clams and Fried Calamari are ideal for starters, while daily specials keep things interesting for regulars. Portions are generous, and everything is served with that no-frills, homey style that keeps guests coming back.

The bar at Old Street is a true centerpiece. It offers a wide selection of beers on tap—both domestic staples and local craft brews—along with classic cocktails and a rotating drink menu. The Irish Coffee and Spiked Apple Cider are seasonal favorites, and happy hour draws a loyal after-work crowd.

At night, Old Street Pub shifts into a local hotspot. Live music, trivia nights, and a bustling bar scene give the place an upbeat energy without losing its cozy feel. It’s the kind of venue where you can watch the game, catch up with friends, or enjoy a casual dinner before heading out—or just staying put.

With its comfortable setting, consistently good food, and no-fuss vibe, Old Street Pub remains a cornerstone of the Smithtown dining and social scene. It’s more than a restaurant—it’s a local tradition.