Umberto's Ranked Top 5 Pizzerias On Long Island
5 stars - based on 1 review
633 Jericho Turnpike New Hyde Park, NY 11040
(516) 437-7698 Categories: Pizza , Italian Price Range: $$ Takes Reservations: Yes
×

Umberto's Ranked Top 5 Pizzerias On Long Island New Hyde Park

A Classic Slice of New Hyde Park
What Kind Of Food Do They Serve: Pizza, Italian
Long Island Blogger
Long Island Blogger

If you're in New Hyde Park and craving classic Italian comfort food, look no further than Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant. A beloved staple in the community, this family-owned gem has mastered the art of traditional Italian cooking, delivering hearty meals and authentic flavors that never miss.

The moment you step inside, you're greeted with a warm, welcoming atmosphere — think old-school Italian charm with modern touches. The buzz of happy diners, the aroma of garlic and fresh tomato sauce, and the sight of golden-baked pizzas create an inviting ambiance perfect for families, dates, or a casual solo bite.

Start with their famous Grandma Pizza — thin, square, and perfectly crisp, with a light layer of tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and a touch of basil. It’s a local legend for good reason. The chicken rollatini, stuffed with prosciutto and gooey cheese, is rich and indulgent, while their eggplant parmigiana hits all the right notes with its tender layers and savory marinara.

Seafood lovers will want to try the linguine with white clam sauce, bursting with briny freshness and garlic-infused olive oil. And for a cozy, filling favorite, the baked ziti is as satisfying as it gets.

Complement your meal with a glass from their well-curated wine list or opt for a classic Italian soda. Be sure to leave room for dessert — the cannoli and tiramisu are house-made and as sweet as the service.

Umberto’s offers both dine-in and takeout, and their portions are generous without compromising on quality. Whether you're a lifelong fan or a first-time visitor, this is a place where tradition, flavor, and hospitality shine through every dish.

Short on time? Grab a slice at the counter — it’s some of the best pizza you’ll find in Nassau County.

Umberto’s is more than a pizzeria — it’s a piece of Long Island culinary heritage worth savoring.

633 Jericho Turnpike  |  New Hyde Park  |  NY  | 11040 | (516) 437-7698
Near By
Long Island Blogger:

Bold Mexican Flavors with a High-Energy Lounge Vibe

1270 Union Turnpike | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Elegant Indian Dining with Rich Flavors and Warm Hospitality

27111 Union Tpke | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Galo Tavern 18 – Charming, Cozy Pub & Grill in New Hyde Park

265-11 Union Tpke | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Lively Japanese Dining with Fresh Sushi & Interactive Hibachi

2311 Jericho Tpke | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Authentic Chettinadu & South Indian Cuisine in New Hyde Park

1635 Hillside Ave | New Hyde Park

Long Island Blogger:

Elevated American Dining in the Heart of Floral Park

1218 Jericho Turnpike | New Hyde Park