Perched near the water in Bayville, NY, Piccolo Cantina Bay offers a vibrant twist on Mexican cuisine with a coastal touch and a refined atmosphere. This stylish cantina pairs bold, authentic flavors with modern plating and a breezy, relaxed setting that makes every meal feel like a mini escape.

🌮 What to Order

Start your meal with the tableside guacamole — creamy, fresh, and made to your exact spice level. Pair it with a mezcal margarita or the house hibiscus sangria for a perfect intro to what's ahead. The shrimp ceviche is a standout appetizer: citrusy, refreshing, and beautifully plated.

For mains, the birria tacos are a must — tender, slow-cooked beef wrapped in crispy, cheese-seared tortillas with rich consommé for dipping. Seafood lovers should try the grilled mahi-mahi tacos or chili-lime shrimp bowl, both of which showcase bright, coastal-inspired flavors.

Vegetarians aren’t left out — the roasted veggie enchiladas are hearty and satisfying, topped with a flavorful verde sauce. Don’t forget a side of elote (Mexican street corn) or the poblano rice — both bring comfort and complexity to the table.

🍸 Drinks & Desserts

Piccolo Cantina Bay features a full bar with creative cocktails and an impressive selection of tequilas and mezcals. The passionfruit margarita is a crowd-pleaser, and the jalapeño-cucumber mule adds a spicy-sweet twist. End your meal with the churros with Mexican chocolate sauce or the light and creamy tres leches cake — both are indulgent and beautifully executed.

🌅 Ambiance & Vibe

The decor blends beachy elegance with rustic charm — think wood beams, soft lighting, and water views if you're lucky enough to snag a seat by the window. It's chic yet inviting, ideal for everything from romantic dinners to upscale group outings.